Published: 2024 | Genre: Psychological Thriller | Pages: 352 | Rating: ★★★★☆
Hooked from the First Page
Okay, I need to talk about Beautiful Ugly by Alice Feeney because this book had me flipping pages like a maniac. Released in 2024, it’s the kind of psychological thriller that makes you question everything and trust no one. I’m a huge fan of Feeney’s creepy vibes—Rock Paper Scissors was a wild ride—so I dove into this one expecting a mind-bender, and wow, it delivered. If you love The Echo of Lies or get a kick out of stories that keep you guessing, this is your next read. Here’s why Beautiful Ugly had me glued and who’s gonna love it—no spoilers, I promise!
What’s It All About?
The story follows Jo, a woman who seems to have it all: a charming husband, a cozy coastal cottage, and a new baby. But when strange things start happening—like eerie noises at night and a feeling she’s being watched—Jo’s perfect life starts to crack. Is her husband hiding something? Is her mind playing tricks? Or is someone out to destroy her? The plot twists through secrets, lies, and a past that won’t stay buried, all set in a sleepy seaside town that feels anything but safe.
Feeney’s setting is so creepy yet so familiar. That small-town vibe, with foggy beaches and nosy neighbors, hit me right in the gut—I grew up near the coast, so I could practically smell the salt air. It’s the kind of place you’d love to visit, but not after reading this!
Why I Couldn’t Put It Down
Feeney’s writing is like a friend whispering a scary story—it pulls you in and won’t let go. Jo’s such a real character: a tired new mom, a bit paranoid, but so relatable you’re rooting for her instantly. The way Feeney builds suspense, dropping tiny clues that make you second-guess everything, is genius. I kept texting my friend, “What?! No way!” at every twist. The short chapters make it impossible to stop—you’re like, “Okay, one more,” and suddenly it’s midnight.
The story’s themes of trust and betrayal got under my skin. In 2025, when we’re all wondering who we can really count on, Jo’s unraveling felt so personal. The way Feeney plays with what’s real and what’s not is next-level. Plus, the cast—shady neighbors, a too-perfect husband—keeps you suspecting everyone. It’s a rollercoaster of “Did that just happen?” moments that make thrillers so fun.
Any Letdowns?
Beautiful Ugly is a blast, but it’s not perfect. The start takes a bit to rev up, with a lot of focus on Jo’s daily life that might feel slow if you’re craving instant drama. Some twists, while shocking, felt a tad far-fetched—like, would that really happen? I also wanted more backstory on a few side characters, like Jo’s neighbor, who seemed juicy but didn’t get enough spotlight. Still, these are small gripes in a book that kept me on edge.
Who’s Gonna Love It?
If you’re into psychological thrillers with domestic drama, unreliable narrators, and jaw-dropping twists, this is for you. Fans of The Guest by B.A. Paris or Gone Girl will eat it up. It’s perfect for readers who love creepy settings and stories that mess with your head, great for ages 16+ due to psychological tension and mild violence. If you’re more into action-packed plots like Onyx Storm, the slower, mind-game vibe might not hit the same.
Why It’s a Big Deal
Beautiful Ugly is all over BookTok in 2025, with fans freaking out over Feeney’s twists. Her knack for making everyday life terrifying is unmatched, and this book feels so fresh in a genre full of predictable plots. Good Housekeeping called it “a chilling masterpiece,” and I totally get why. As a standalone, it’s a complete, satisfying read, but I’m already hoping Feeney drops another thriller soon.
My Final Take
Beautiful Ugly is a twisty, chilling thriller that’ll keep you guessing until the last page. Alice Feeney spins a web of lies and suspense, with a heroine you’ll cheer for through every shock. I’m giving it four out of five stars for its gripping plot and creepy vibes, with a tiny dip for the slow start. If you’re ready to lose sleep over Jo’s story, grab this book and hold on tight.
Want to unravel this twisted tale? Snag Beautiful Ugly at your local bookstore or check Bookshop.org to support indie sellers. Read it yet? Spill your thoughts in the comments!
